John Rawls proposes an ideal theory of a cooperative society, while Alexander Rawls considers a different question: what is the place of justice in a society where it cannot be assumed that productive cooperation is universal, where cooperation and solutions to collective-action problems are not independent of incentives.

This full text of this article will be available online nine months after its initial print publication. To read it now, please buy this issue in print or eBook format from our store, or in the new Independent Review app on iOS or Google Play, or on Magzter which offers digital access on smartphones, tablets, and web browsers.