Although well-written and sometimes illuminating, Nancy McClean’s Democracy in Chains: The Deep History of the Radical Right’s Steal Plan for America is so factually unreliable and tenuously argued that it is best viewed not has a serious work of historical investigation, but rather as a work of speculative historical fiction. Rather than expose the nefarious, “anti-democratic” motives of the public choice movement, and its founder James M. Buchanan, McClean’s misinformed and misguided book is an object lesson in how not to do intellectual history.

View the full text of the article here, or download the PDF below.

Michael C. Munger is Senior Fellow and former co-editor of The Independent Review at the Independent Institute, and Professor of Political Science, Economics and Public Policy and Director of the Philosophy, Politics, and Economics Program at Duke University.
Twitter      Email
EconomistsEconomyPhilosophy and Religion
Other Independent Review articles by Michael C. Munger
Spring 2024 Following Their Leaders: Political Preferences and Public Policy
Spring 2024 The Origins and Evolution of Consumer Capitalism; Crack-Up Capitalism
Winter 2023/24 The Classical Liberal Diaspora
[View All (80)]