A Postmortem on the 2025 Government Shutdown
November 18, 2025

The federal government shutdown limped to an end after 43 days. The shutdown began on October 1, 2025, just after the U.S. government’s 2025 fiscal year ended. Without the U.S. Congress passing spending bills to authorize funds to continue government operations in the new 2026 fiscal year, President Trump was forced to shutter the government’s nonessential operations. That wasn’t his choice; it’s required under the Antideficiency Act of 1982.
There was a way the 2025 shutdown could have been avoided. Congress could pass a temporary spending bill to fund government operations while continuing to hammer out regular spending bills. The Republican majority in the House of Representatives drafted a straightforward Continuing Resolution to do just that, sending the bill to the Senate, well before the government would shut down.
That’s when things went wrong. Members of the Democratic Party in the Senate joined together to filibuster the continuing resolution. With 100 members, the Senate requires 60 votes to end debate on a bill before it goes forward for a real up-or-down vote. The votes in favor, cast by 52 of 53 Republicans in the Senate, weren’t enough to advance to the real vote.
The Senate Democrats refused to vote to advance the continuing resolution because they wanted to undo the Medicaid reforms that came with the passage of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act in July. They also demanded that the Republicans keep a temporary boost to Affordable Care Act subsidies going after they were set to expire at the end of 2025, under the terms of a law that Senate Democrats wrote and passed when they had full control of Congress.
In the end, the Senate Democrats caved, after it became apparent that welfare payments for food for 42 million Americans would not be made, and as flights began to be grounded due to a lack of air traffic controllers, who were going unpaid because of the shutdown. Eight Democratic Senators, none of whom will face voters in the next congressional elections, cut a deal to restart the U.S. government’s operations.
In the end, the Senate Democrats didn’t get anything they claimed they wanted.
If there’s anything we’ve learned from any of the 21 government shutdowns that have taken place since 1977, it’s that shutting down the government doesn’t work very well as a political strategy.
The lessons of the longest-ever government shutdown also argue strongly in favor of moving more operations out of the federal government’s hands. Why should regular Americans be inconvenienced because the federal government plays by such dumb rules? Would any flight ever need to be cancelled during a government shutdown if private businesses operated air traffic control, as they do in Canada? For that matter, would any national park ever need to close in a shutdown if its admission gates were operated by private organizations, or even by state governments?
Think about it. What is it that we really need the federal government to do for us? Shouldn’t everything that isn’t on that list be taken out of Uncle Sam’s hands? Shouldn’t we consider implementing protections for those initiatives to prevent potential shutdowns that may arise from political disagreements?
After 21 shutdowns, one would think that politicians would have learned their lesson by now.























