I understand that old people (thats me) always think the younger generation is confused and likely to lead us to disaster. But....cmon. Isnt it true this time? Hasnt our education system produced a giant cohort of fragile snowflakes and petty tyrants?
It looks like it. At UNC Chapel Hill this week a flier was discovered, hundreds of copies of which had been distributed around the campus. It encouraged students to bash the fash!, meaning physically assault fascists. The definition of fascist, conveniently, appears to be anyone who disagrees with the smothering leftist orthodoxy that the flier-istas embrace.
One sign of fascism, according to the flier, is the wearing of a Make America Great Again! ball cap. Since that is the symbol of our current President, a substantial part of the population is fascist. Earlier in the week, a set of instructionsof unknown origincirculated nationwide. This meme claimed that Its okay to punch Nazis, and of course white male libertarians who advocate free speech. If you disagree with me, I get to punch you, provided Im one of the annointed who has politically correct views.
There are two difficulties here. First, these advocates are confused about the role of violence as being effective for their side. The state specializes in violence. It has (and, in fact, must have) guns, helicopters, tanks, and fighter jets. Our leftist zealots have no hope of resisting the power of the state. If it comes to violence, the state will win.
The bullies of the left are physically brave when confronting a few, isolated fascists on their ideologically segregated college campuses and safe spaces. But if violence starts, thats not where it will end. President Trump this week has considered drafting national guard troops for immigration enforcement. Even if one grants (and I dont) that the Trump side is dangerous, bringing a pocketknife to a machine-gunfight is going to turn out badly. The last thing that the political minority should advocate is violence.
Second, and more fundamentally, the right that is being invoked and relied on by the left is precisely freedom of speech. The very capacity being counted is the right to dissent. And I am a big fan of the right to dissent. Thats the reason that Im a libertarian in the first place.
But many in the new generation of political activists assume that they will control the coercive power that decides who gets to speak, and who is bashed. Whenever they arent, of course, they are the first to advocate free speech rights, to be exercised by themselves and those who agree with them.
Thats not how it works. I understand that it is difficult when young people find themselves betrayed by democracy. Its a stunning realization when you discover that a substantial part of the American population disagrees with you. After all, you took classes at the best schools, where they told you how smart you are; you gathered into discussion groups where I feel that... counts as an argument. You feel right now, for the first time, that the U.S. is heading in the wrong direction. Welcome to my world, except that Ive had that feeling for decades.
A generation whose entire experience with politics was vacuously validated by the Obama mass-hypnoses of 2008 and 2012 is suddenly confronted with the fact that one must persuade people. You cant force them to agree with you. Because if anyone is going to be subjected to force, its the political minority. Rather than bashing, you might want to try talking to the folks who disagree with you. At worst, youd be asserting the right to talk, and to disagree, even if your side no longer controls the coercive apparatus of the state.
|Michael C. Munger is Senior Fellow and Co-Editor of The Independent Review at the Independent Institute, and Professor of Political Science, Economics and Public Policy and Director of the Philosophy, Politics, and Economics Program at Duke University.|