Artists and Markets In Music
Book Review
Reviewed by
This book review appeared in the Summer 2025 issue of The Independent Review.
The COVID-19 pandemic formally ended in May 2023. Damages caused by the virus and governments’ efforts to address it have not. Economists, health care providers, public health professionals, and countless others have worked tirelessly to document these effects and how they affect the immediate future. For all these efforts, I’ve yet to see an analysis of how the COVID-19 pandemic impacted musicians, their work, and the music industry more broadly. Authors Cameron M. Weber, Ying Zhen, and J. J. Arias provide a detailed, rigorous, and intriguing account of these considerations in their excellent work Artists and Markets in Music: The Political Economy of Music During the COVID Era and Beyond.
The book is composed of five chapters, culminating in a political economy analysis of the music industry during the pandemic and findings of a survey conducted by the authors. It begins by asking a difficult question: Who is a musical artist? Not satisfied with the standard economist’s definition that a musician is “someone who makes a living through creating music” (p. 1), the artists provide a detailed account of the role of art and artists in society. Unlike many professions, artists create their works for the enjoyment of others and for themselves. Artists’ vocations are also often avocations. Further, their work and its impact entangle social norms, social classes, as well as theories of genius and beauty. As the authors note, many sociologists and aesthetic philosophers disagree strongly on what constitutes art and how it impacts—and even categorizes—society.
Ultimately, the authors settle on two insights to categorize art, music, and its practitioners. First, borrowing heavily from the Austrian school of economics, the value of art for the consumer and producer is subjective. Second, all artists are entrepreneurs—serving to allocate resources to more desirable uses. Further, as they elaborate, “good art can come through in bad times—scarcity being the mother of invention” (p. 4). Emphasizing the entrepreneurial role of the artist places the authors’ work with much of the recent work of Ennio E. Piano and his coauthors (for example, see “Contracting Creativity: Patronage and Creative Freedom in the Italian Renaissance Art Market,” European Review of Economic History 27 [3]: 311–35 and “Specialization and the Firm in Renaissance Italian Art,” Journal of Cultural Economics 46:659–97).
Their work continues in the Austrian economics tradition. In chapter 2 they incorporate F. A. Hayek’s concept of the catallaxy and stages of production diagrams to explain the production process of music as it transitions from creative processes to primary and secondary markets. While complex, readers will quickly understand the role of competition and innovation through the process of creative destruction involved on the supply side of the music market. In one of the more intriguing parts of the book, the authors explain how systems of markets allow for diverse music interests— including highbrow, working-class, and so-called “superstar influenced” popular music—and how preferences for less popular music are incorporated and produced with the help of platform apps.
Later in chapter 2, the authors address two common concerns with the free market approach to analyzing the market for music: superstar musicians resulting in rising inequality and the “price ticketing curse.” Emphasizing the catallatic point of view, the authors argue that less-regulated markets are the primary way to reduce inequality of earnings among musicians. Further, any “superstar effects” are surely mitigated by the music market’s ability to provide a wide selection of music and musical performances to audiences of diverse tastes. The price ticketing curse can be described as organizations “wanting to sell their event (perishable good) ticket at a ‘fair price’ to satisfy their supporters of the arts but the secondary markets price for these events at what the host organization [assumed to be a non-profit] sees as an unvirtuous level” (p. 42). In response, the authors highlight the ambiguity in determining a “fair price” and note that secondary markets provide a means to reallocate goods toward higher-valued uses.
Chapter 3 addresses the complicated role that copyright pirating plays in the music industry. Copyright laws grant musicians many monopoly rights to their music. Pirating music makes musicians’ work widely available—often at a price of zero. Historically, the widespread use of pirating software prompted musicians to perform more live music, utilize more streaming services, and promote merchandise. However, the impact of copyrights and pirating on consumers, musicians, and social welfare is complex. To further illustrate the costs and benefits for each party, the authors spend much of the chapter developing three mathematical models. Their models derive their propositions. First, musicians will produce less music and the music industry will be worse off the more restrictive COVID-19 lockdowns become. Second, if piracy of music is sufficiently large, it will bolster the demand for live performances and possibly offset potential losses to the musician. Third, if copyright protections are sufficiently high, it may reduce the market for complementary goods and limit music production. Consequently, removing copyright protections could be welfare enhancing—improving customer satisfaction and musician profitability.
Chapter 4 explores the political economy of government’s relationship to the music industry and in response to COVID-19. Borrowing again from Hayek, the authors hold society is more than the sum of its members, and that previous events help to shape broader social structures. The authors also use insights from Anthony de Jasay, Richard Wagner, and Robert Higgs to develop a theory of state action to maintain its social image during a crisis. Interestingly, the authors note that musicians made more use of crowdfunding, engaged in more collaborative efforts with other musicians, and extended their artistic expressions into other forms of music during the COVID-19 pandemic. As non-essential workers who benefit from concerts and live music to bolster income, musicians were also particularly affected by government responses to COVID-19. Consequently, many governments faced “localized pushback” from musicians and music fans (p. 79).
The last chapter reviews the authors’ survey results conducted on musicians before and during the COVID-19 pandemic. Before the pandemic, most musicians found serendipity and authenticity played an important role in music creation. Most did believe belonging to a union was crucial for success. Similarly, few thought an education was important to succeed as a musician. During the COVID-19 pandemic, musicians collaborated more often with other musicians—but many found this difficult. Most musicians financially struggled and subjectively found themselves worse off during the pandemic. The only exception was musicians who use stimulants when creating music. These musicians also engaged in more streaming services and found ways to boost income during the pandemic. Further details into how the survey was constructed and administered and how the results were calculated are provided to the reader in five appendixes.
The book is timely and clearly written. The authors should be praised for seamlessly integrating philosophy, Austrian economics, political economy, contemporary policy controversies in the music industry, theories of state perseverance, and findings from a survey in a relatively short book. Ample use of clear and interesting case studies bolsters the authors’ approach and arguments. Despite their expressed concerns of straw manning their detractors, I found their representation of opposing views to be fair (and well rebutted). Most importantly, the book provides a clear and thought-provoking assessment of how COVID- 19 (and the government’s response to it) impacted the music industry. It’s a vastly underexamined component of post-pandemic research—and the authors provide a convincing and engaging account.
I do have some criticisms of the book. While I found the mathematical models used in chapter 3 (and in chapter 4 to a lesser extent) interesting, I worry they will disinterest or confuse some readers. The propositions and implications of these models are also never illustrated or tested directly in the book through other research, the authors’ survey results, or anecdotal evidence. I also found the authors’ use of multiple theories of state action during the pandemic to be overzealous. Focusing more narrowly on Higgs’s framework for government expansion (Crisis and Leviathan, Oxford University Press, 1987) or the Public Choice insight of moral theater (see, for instance, Geoffrey Brennan and Loren L. Lomasky, Democracy and Decision: The Pure Theory of Electoral Preference, Cambridge University Press, 1992) would more clearly convey their framework to analyze government. Either approach would likely be more convincing for an academic reader and more approachable for a lay audience.
I believe the authors miss an opportunity to expand upon how music affected or demonstrated distrust of government during the later pandemic period. This is somewhat frustrating given the amount of emphasis the authors put on efforts taken by government during COVID- 19 to maintain its image. Public efforts to undermine and question government authority and information are often captured in music. The book also fails to hypothesize how COVID-19 responses will change the music industry going forward. Speculating what music will look like and how it will be delivered during the “new normal” would be especially interesting.
Nearly everyone was impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic (and their government’s response to it). Determining the aftermath of this crisis will remain a research project for decades. Artists and Markets in Music: The Political Economy of Music During the COVID Era and Beyond provides an excellent and readable assessment of the harms, consequences, and response of the pandemic and government measures for musicians and the music industry. It’s a challenging assignment and unique topic—and one that scholars and most lay audiences will enjoy reading.
Comments
Related Book Reviews
Independent Review Issues
Articles by Issue










