Skip to content
Stay Connected
Facebook
X (Twitter)
Youtube
Rumble
Instagram
LinkedIn
  • Cart
Independent Institute
  • About
    • People
      • Fellows
      • Board of Directors
      • Board of Advisors
      • Staff
    • Awards & Accreditations
      • Awards Received
      • Alexis de Tocqueville Award
    • Annual Reports
    • Student Programs
    • Financial Information
    • Careers
    • Contact
  • Research
    • Priorities
      • Sparking Entrepreneurship & Innovation
      • Defending Civil Liberties
      • Educating the Next Generation
    • Issues
      • Economy
      • Education
      • Law & Liberty
      • Energy & Environment
      • Regulation
      • Culture & Society
      • All Issues
    • Projects & Initiatives
      • The American West
      • Ethnic Studies Curriculum
      • Exposing Socialism
      • History of Communism
      • Inequality Fact Check
      • Liberty at 250
      • Love Gov
      • Privacy and Tech Freedom
      • Rent vs. Buy Calculator
      • Reset Report
      • Responsible Economics
    • Centers
      • Educational Excellence
      • Entrepreneurial Innovation
      • Global Prosperity
      • Health & Environment
      • Law & Justice
      • Peace & Liberty
    • Books
    • The Independent Review
    • Publish with Us
    • Explore All Research
  • News
    • News Articles
    • Book Reviews
    • Independent in the News
    • News Releases
    • Quarterly Newsletter
    • News Library
  • Events
  • Video & Audio
    • Video
    • Audio
    • Podcast: History of the Future
    • Podcast: Independent Conversations
    • Podcast: The Independent with Scott Atlas
    • Love Gov
  • Store
    • Books
    • The Independent Review: Subscribe
    • The Independent Review: Buy Single Issues
    • Customer Account Login
  • Donate
  • Search
  • Search
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Law & Liberty
  • Energy & the Environment
  • Culture & Society
  • Regulation
  • More Issues
Home / News / News Releases / Detail

For Immediate Release

January 15, 2009

News Release

Stephen Halbrook To Testify Against Confirmation of Eric Holder for Attorney General at Senate Judiciary Committee Hearing

OAKLAND, Calif., Jan. 15, 2009—Today the Senate Judiciary Committee is holding a hearing for the controversial nomination of Eric Holder to the position of Attorney General of the United States.

Independent Institute Research Fellow and attorney Stephen Halbrook is among the witnesses testifying, arguing that Holder’s reputation as a steadfast opponent of Second Amendment rights makes him an unfit candidate for the job.

Halbrook, author of the new Institute book The Founders’ Second Amendment: Origins of the Right to Bear Arms, filed an amicus brief on behalf of more than 300 members of Congress in the recent Supreme Court case District of Columbia v. Heller. But the landmark decision, affirming an individual right in the Second Amendment, conflicts with Holder’s track record, claims Halbrook. In fact, Holder joined in a brief arguing that the Second Amendment only concerns the “State’s operation of a well-regulated militia” and does not protect an individual right, a position at odds with President-elect Barack Obama’s approval of Heller.

“When Mr. Holder served as Deputy Attorney General (1997–2001) and Acting Attorney General (2001), the Department of Justice implemented policies hostile to Second Amendment rights,” states Halbrook in his prepared written testimony. “In the establishment of the national instant criminal background check system (‘NICS’) in 1998, the Department claimed the authority to keep records on lawful firearm purchasers for an alleged ‘audit log’ for six months, despite the law’s requirement that such records be destroyed and its prohibition on registration of firearm owners.”

“In that same period, the Department circulated draft legislation that would be included in a bill introduced by Congressman John Conyers as H.R. 1768 (106th Cong., 1999). The bill would have: Imposed felony penalties on a person who planned a gun show without registering with and reporting to ATF; made it unlawful for persons under age 21 to possess firearms, even though they vote, serve on juries, and serve in the military; imposed a 3-day waiting period, and limited handgun purchases to one per month.”

“After terrorists struck with box cutters on 9/11, Mr. Holder responded with an op ed arguing for ‘background checks on all gun sales,’ which would have extended felony penalties to the otherwise innocent, intrastate conduct of law-abiding private individuals. He added: ‘Congress should also pass legislation that would give the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms a record of every firearm sale.’ Under the guise of combating terrorism, every American firearm owner would thus be registered with the government,” Halbrook states.

Continuing to reveal Holder as a staunch opponent of the Second Amendment, Halbrook concludes, “Eric Holder has taken a constricted view of Second Amendment rights. Millions of law-abiding Americans exercise the right to keep and bear arms. Mr. Holder’s opinion is that the people have no such right unless they are commanded to exercise it in a formal militia, which renders the right meaningless. . . . Many Americans have reason to be uneasy about Mr. Holder’s nomination for Attorney General. They deserve to have a person in this role who is committed to upholding all parts of the Constitution, including the Second Amendment. Unfortunately, Mr. Holder has proven himself not to be that person.”

# # #

Stay Connected to the Independent Institute

Sign up to receive periodic updates of the latest news, research, events, and publications.

"*" indicates required fields

Subscribe

View All Options

Beyond Homeless
Beyond Homeless
MyGovCost
FDAReview.org
Independent Institute
Independent Institute

The Independent Institute
100 Swan Way
Oakland, CA 94621-1428

Phone (510) 632-1366
Fax (510) 568-6040

Follow Us

Facebook
X (Twitter)
Youtube
Rumble
Instagram
LinkedIn
  • About
  • Fellows
  • Board of Directors
  • Board of Advisors
  • Staff
  • Awards & Accreditations
  • Alexis de Tocqueville Award
  • Reviews
  • Student Programs
  • Financial Information
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • News
  • News Articles
  • Book Reviews
  • Independent in the News
  • News Releases
  • Events
  • Quarterly Newsletter
  • News Library
  • Store
  • Books
  • The Independent Review: Subscribe
  • The Independent Review: Buy Single Issues
  • Customer Account Login
  • Return Policy
  • Research
  • Priorities
  • Issues
  • Projects & Initiatives
  • Centers
  • Books
  • The Independent Review
  • Publish with Us
  • Explore All Research
  • Donate
  • Ways to Support the Independent Institute
  • Membership Benefits
  • Leave a Legacy
  • David J. Theroux Chair Endowment Fund
  • Donor’s Bill of Rights
  • Contact
  • All Issues
  • Newsletter Sign Up
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2026 Independent Institute - All Rights Reserved

Page load link
Independent Institute
  • About
  • Fellows
  • Board of Directors
  • Board of Advisors
  • Staff
  • Awards & Accreditations
  • Alexis de Tocqueville Award
  • Reviews
  • Student Programs
  • Financial Information
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Research
  • Priorities
  • Issues
  • Projects & Initiatives
  • Centers
  • Books
  • The Independent Review
  • Publish with Us
  • Explore All Research
  • News
  • News Articles
  • Book Reviews
  • Independent in the News
  • News Releases
  • Events
  • Quarterly Newsletter
  • News Library
  • Video & Audio
  • Video
  • Audio
  • Podcast: History of the Future
  • Podcast: Independent Conversations
  • Podcast: The Independent with Scott Atlas
  • Love Gov
  • Store
  • Books
  • The Independent Review: Subscribe
  • The Independent Review: Buy Single Issues
  • Customer Account Login
  • Return Policy
  • Donate
  • Ways to Support the Independent Institute
  • Membership Benefits
  • Establish Your Legacy of Liberty
  • David J. Theroux Chair Endowment Fund
  • Donor’s Bill of Rights
  • Contact
Stay Connected

Follow Us

Facebook
X (Twitter)
Youtube
Rumble
Instagram
LinkedIn
Trending
Nov 6, 2026

Becerra Takes the Gravy Train

New California governor promised to complete bankrupt bullet-train “on time and on budget.”
By K. Lloyd Billingsley
Read Now
158859350_m
Nov 6, 2026

A New Factory Isn't Necessarily a Sign of Growth

Gains to players in the political game do not necessarily mean gains for the rest of us.
By Randy Simmons, Diana W. Thomas
Read Now
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Health Freedom Rally Times Square
Nov 5, 2026

Make America Healthy Again Meets Public Choice

The political incentives behind health policy help explain why reform is easier to promise than to achieve.
By Raymond J. March
Read Now
An elderly couple explores products inside a local store in Portugal, highlighting everyday life.
Nov 3, 2026

The Food Is Fine. The Recall Process Isn’t.

Why increased recall warnings don’t mean our food supply is getting worse.
By Raymond J. March
Read Now
Go to Top