The Third Rail Is Dead
It’s time to rethink Social Security.
October 16, 2026
News Article
It’s time to rethink Social Security.
Washington has spent decades ignoring the growing Social Security problem. (see the figures on SSA.gov and deficit projections on Mercatus.org) “The combined cost of the Social Security and Medicare programs is projected to rise from 9.4 percent of GDP in 2026 to 12.5 percent of GDP in 2050 and to 14.2 percent in 2100.”
Everyone knows the math is getting worse. Americans are living longer. Birth rates are falling. Fewer workers are supporting more retirees. The Social Security trustees project the program’s trust funds will be depleted in the early 2030s, leaving payroll taxes insufficient to pay all scheduled benefits unless Congress acts.

Social Security’s 75-Year Deficit as a percentage of taxable payroll, 1983-2026. Source: Social Security Trustees Report.
Yet every election brings the same warning: Don’t touch my Social Security! That is why President Donald Trump’s reported interest in Australia’s retirement system matters. Not because Australia has discovered the silver bullet for that fiscal monster, but because someone in Washington is finally asking whether a retirement system designed during the Great Depression is still the best America can do in the 21st century.
Social Security was created for a very different country. In 1935, workers vastly outnumbered retirees. A newborn’s life expectancy in the U.S.A. was about 60 years. Families were larger. Based on Bismarck’s model, FDR’s pay-as-you-go system seemed like a good idea because demographics made it work. Those conditions are gone. According to the Social Security Trustees’ estimates, by the end of this century, America must pay approximately $112 trillion in benefits. Projections indicate that trust fund balances and new revenue from taxing current workers will not exceed $82 trillion. That is a $30 trillion deficit! Social Security will be able to pay only 73% of its promises.
Today, Americans routinely spend decades in retirement. Fertility has declined. The ratio of workers supporting each beneficiary has steadily fallen from 160 to less than 3. According to the Congressional Budget Office, population aging is one of the principal drivers of long-term federal spending growth. Politicians who go into election mode every other year naturally ignore such arithmetic. They cannot repeal reality. The longer Washington waits, the fewer choices remain.

Source: Social Security Administration. Reposted from AEI.org.
Australia demonstrates that there is another way to think about retirement security (charts available at APRA.gov). The defining feature of the superannuation system is not mandatory saving. It’s ownership. Workers accumulate funds in their own retirement accounts. Those accounts are invested over decades in diversified portfolios that grow with the economy. The assets belong to workers and can provide retirement income independent of future tax collections. That is a fundamentally different philosophy: Ownership changes incentives and creates wealth.
People who own retirement assets have a direct stake in economic growth. They benefit from pro-market reforms, expanding businesses, stronger investment returns, and rising productivity. They participate in capitalism rather than relying almost entirely on future taxpayers. A nation of owners is stronger than a nation of beneficiaries.
America already recognizes this principle. Millions of workers save through 401(k)s, Individual Retirement Accounts, and the federal Thrift Savings Plan. Those accounts have helped millions build substantial retirement wealth. But participation remains uneven. A typical working adult (25 to 64) has less than $1,000 in their savings account. Even for those who try to be prudent, the median balance is just $40,000—woefully inadequate to meet their needs.
1 in 5 Americans over the age of 50 has saved absolutely nothing. 2 out of 5 households whose careers will end within the next decade have no retirement accounts. Too many Americans reach their golden years entirely dependent on Social Security. Australia took a different approach. Instead of hoping workers would save enough, it made retirement saving a normal part of working life. They also kept a public safety net for those who need one.
No system is perfect, of course. Australia’s system has been revised repeatedly. Policymakers have adjusted contribution rates, improved transparency, strengthened governance, and addressed concerns over fees and tax treatment. That is what responsible public servants should do. The lesson is that demographic change requires institutional change. For too long, America has been reluctant to admit that. Generations of politicians treated any discussion of Social Security reform as political suicide. But every year Congress postpones reform, fewer options remain. Problems that could have been solved early are becoming a crisis.
Most Americans rightly believe that seniors should not face destitution in old age. But why should retirement security depend almost entirely on promises from future politicians when workers could also build wealth they actually own? That is the debate America started at the turn of the century. Both Presidents Clinton and Bush supported the reform. Trump is right to put the issue back on the table. Australia may not have all the answers, but refusing to ask new questions guarantees a collapse of an outdated retirement system.
The architects of Social Security built a program that reflected the realities of their time. Honoring that achievement doesn’t require preserving every feature of their design forever. It requires showing the same willingness to adapt that they did.
Americans deserve a pension plan built on more than political promises. They deserve the opportunity to enjoy their old age with the wealth that belongs to them. As economist Jose Pinera recently noted, it’s time to “embrace the capitalization system that is anchored in ownership of retirement savings, individual freedom, and personal responsibility.”


























