Reconciliation Should Heal, Not Hollow Out the Rule of Law
Canada’s property rights are under serious threat.
January 22, 2026
News Article
Canada’s property rights are under serious threat.
In 2025, Canadian politics experienced significant upheaval, marked by the departure of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau after a decade of ineffective leadership. The Liberal Party, led by Mark Carney, began to rise again, while trade relations between the United States and Canada plummeted to an all-time low. One issue that does not receive enough media coverage is how the country’s Truth and Reconciliation efforts concerning its Indigenous people have lost sight of sound principles of justice and now threaten private property rights and undermine economic prosperity.
What Truth and Reconciliation Was Meant to Do
Canadians suffer from a profound sense of collective guilt for their historical treatment of Indigenous peoples. In 2008, the government established a Truth and Reconciliation Commission to determine whether Aboriginal children were abused and if any children died due to inhumane treatment. The TRC’s final report noted that thousands of children died and were buried in unmarked graves on residential school property. As recently as June 17, 2024, former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau spoke at an Aboriginal event and stated that unmarked graves have been found, blaming Christian churches, which then led to the burning of 100 churches, which Trudeau described as “understandable.” The federal government has extended numerous apologies and allocated substantial financial resources to native communities, and in 2022, the Pope visited, expressing remorse. The Canadian Parliament passed a unanimous motion condemning Canada’s residential school system for committing genocide.
There is no doubt that abuse took place in residential schools, conditions were poor, and when the 1918 Spanish flu hit, the children paid the price. However, the extent of such abuse has been a subject of debate. Though gravesites have been alleged, to date, no physical remains have been discovered, nor have mass graves been identified. At the very least, calling the school system an instrument of genocide is an inappropriate mischaracterization that oversimplifies the complex historical context. Rather than fostering healing through the processes of Truth and Reconciliation, this discourse appears to perpetuate division and support a narrative of grievance among Indigenous communities, attributing blame to European settlers for land theft, the introduction of diseases, and the perpetration of genocidal acts. There is a notable absence of nuanced discourse regarding the contributions of Europeans to the development of North America.
Apologies, Billions, and Worsening Outcomes
When Justin Trudeau became Prime Minister in 2015, he declared that the welfare of Indigenous Canadians was his top priority. He increased the annual budget for Indigenous affairs, raising it from $11 billion in 2015 to $32 billion annually by 2025. Billions were tossed around like confetti, with money going to settle past harms, child and family services, and loan guarantees, while the life of the average native person has not improved. Members of the Indigenous community suffer from a shorter life span, are less likely to graduate from High School, have higher rates of substance abuse, and are more likely to wind up in prison in comparison to the average Canadian. Meanwhile, government transfers continue to outpace revenues generated by First Nations business activities. If anything, the Liberal government has done what it does best: it has made First Nations dependent on federal money.
However, the rubber has begun to hit the road, with a frightening ruling in British Columbia’s supreme court that granted Aboriginal title, the right of Indigenous people to own their own ancestral land, where private businesses and farmers already hold title. According to the ruling, the Cowichan Tribes and First Nations hold title over the land they once used as a fishing village before British colonization. The controversial ruling is likely to be appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada. This decision has significant implications for the B.C. economy and could threaten property rights nationwide. B.C. is already suffering the consequences, with its energy sector losing billions in investments. In 2023, British Columbia’s investment in oil, mining, and gas sectors fell to $7.7 billion, 24 percent below the record $10.2 billion reached in 2011. This collapse occurred at a time when global energy demand continues to rise.
Canadians believe their homes, farms, savings, cars, and small businesses are theirs, but they are only protected by common law and statutes. Unlike in the U.S., where the Bill of Rights guarantees property rights, Canada does not have explicit constitutional protection, and the government can expropriate private land for public use at any time. The culprit behind the emerging property rights crisis is Section 35 of the country’s constitution, which prioritizes Aboriginal rights over the Charter rights of ordinary Canadians. In 2014, the Supreme Court of Canada issued a landmark ruling in the case of Tsilhqot’in Nation v. British Columbia, which recognized Aboriginal title as a form of land ownership and contradicted claims of private ownership.
UNDRIP and the Expansion of Indefinite Claims
To make matters worse, British Columbia is the only province in the world to integrate the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP) into law. This means that B.C law must align with UNDRIP. Recently, a B.C court of appeal struck down the province’s mineral system for failing to meet UNDRIP’s consultation and consent requirements. If one follows the endless pages of UNDRIP’s Indigenous rights, they are entitled to everything.
David Eby’s NDP government, which has created the mess, is now declaring that it will “go to the wall” to protect the rights of property owners and wants the province to provide loan guarantees to homeowners if banks don’t offer financing or cannot refinance mortgages. B.C. is a tragedy waiting to happen, as much of its land is not covered by treaties; therefore, more land claims will emerge, causing a freefall in land values, damaging people’s standard of living, and eroding basic freedoms.
The Need for Legal Restraint and Constitutional Clarity
Nobel Prize-winning economist Friedrich Hayek believed that property rights were so important that they predated history. “Law, liberty, and property are an inseparable trinity,” he wrote. In Cuba, after Castro’s 1959 revolution, businesses and the middle class lost their assets overnight. Families that had worked for generations found themselves owning nothing at all. Law professor Paul Warchuk calls for the protection of private property over government encroachment: ”Weak property rights discourage investment, erode public trust, and concentrate power in the state. A society that treats ownership as conditional undermines citizens’ freedoms to plan, build, and innovate.”
Unless the federal government steps in to protect property rights and the Supreme Court of Canada curbs its judicial activism—which seeks to address historical injustices by favoring special interests—doubts about private property ownership will continue to grow, undermining the legal certainty investors need to put capital to work, taking away personal freedoms, and seriously damaging economic prosperity.









