Rights from the Beginning
Analyzing Sen. Tim Kaine’s “constitutional blasphemy”
September 16, 2025
News Article
Analyzing Sen. Tim Kaine’s “constitutional blasphemy”
In a recent Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing, Sen. Tim Kaine proclaimed:
The notion that rights don’t come from laws and don’t come from the government, but come from the Creator — that’s what the Iranian government believes. It’s a theocratic regime that bases its rule on Shia (sic) law and targets Sunnis, Bahá’ís, Jews, Christians, and other religious minorities. They do it because they believe that they understand what natural rights are from their Creator. So, the statement that our rights do not come from our laws or our governments is extremely troubling.
That prompted Pepperdine professor Steven F. Hayward to proclaim it “a bad week for John Locke,” but there was more to it. Hayward, formerly of UC Berkeley, concluded that Sen. Kaine, “has never studied the logic of the famous second paragraph of the Declaration of Independence, or if he has, he rejects the teaching, as do most leftists today.” The idea that our rights come from our Creator is “literally the teaching of the Declaration.” (Hayward’s emphasis)
It was apparent to Hayward that Kaine had never read or studied Thomas Jefferson’s “Statute for Religious Freedom of 1786,” which “connects religious liberty and freedom of conscience (what moderns might call “pluralism” or even “diversity”) with natural rights generally.” Sen. Kaine later claimed he believed in natural rights, but that violated the law of contradiction, which holds that A cannot be non-A.
“Does anyone over the age of six really think the Iranian government believes in government by the consent of the governed,” wondered Hayward, “let alone the rights of conscience as the ground of religious liberty?” The professor proclaimed Kaine the victim of a defective education and if that seems harsh, consider the response of Jonathan Turley, professor of public interest law at George Washington University, in “Tim Kaine’s constitutional blasphemy.”
As Turley explains, “Kaine’s view did exist at the founding—and it was rejected.” Alexander Hamilton wrote that the sacred rights of mankind “are written, as with a sunbeam, in the whole volume of human nature, by the hand of the Divinity itself, and can never be erased or obscured by mortal power.” As Turley holds, “this country was founded on core, shared principles of natural law, including a deep commitment to individual rights against the government. The government was not the source but the scourge of individual rights.” (emphasis added)
Kaine’s view that advocates of natural law are no different from Iranian mullahs applying Sharia law “is not just ill-informed but would have been considered by the founders as constitutionally blasphemous.” Professor Turley is also aware of the alternative view.
“If our rights are based not in natural law but rather in the evolving priorities of lawmakers like Kaine,” professor Turley argues. “Protections then become not the manifestations of human rights, but of rights invented by humans.” Missing in the response to Kaine are the humans most responsible for inventing human rights, as they defined them. That would be Josef Stalin and the Soviet Communists who drafted the USSR’s 1936 constitution.
The principle applied in the U.S.S.R. is that of socialism: “From each according to his ability, to each according to his work,” which is a “duty” performed on “collective farms” and such. The document includes “rights” to education, “free medical service,” and so forth. The Soviet “dictatorship of the proletariat”—the Communist Party—called these substantive rights, as opposed to the “bourgeois” or merely “formal” rights of the American founding.
Medical care is good to have, but since its delivery impinges on the time and labor of others, medical care can’t be a right in the same sense as life and liberty. As a matter of record, the Soviets and Chinese Communists, whose constitution follows the Soviet model, are the worst violators of the most basic human right—the right to life. According to The Black Book of Communism, the Soviets murdered as many as 25 million, and the Chinese more than 60 million.
Even so, as Paul Hollander noted in Political Pilgrims, the USSR became the object of adulation from Western journalists, academics and politicians. Sen. Bernie Sanders, mayor of Burlington, Vermont, at the time, visited the USSR in 1988, praising Soviet housing and health care, which he considers a right. While in the USSR, Sanders criticized the United States, but no word about The Great Terror under Stalin, or other violations of human rights by the Soviet dictatorship.
Stalinist regimes are the showcase for the notion that human rights proceed from the government. Sen. Kaine, a candidate for vice president in 2016, believes this is extremely troubling. For Jonathan Turley, Kaine is “the embodiment of a new crisis of faith in the foundations of our republic on the very eve of its 250th anniversary. This is a crisis of faith not just in our Constitution, but in each other as human beings ‘endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights.’”
The 250th anniversary in 2026 will provide many opportunities to reaffirm those basic rights, which will keep the nation moving forward for the next 250 years and beyond.

























