Prefer to order by phone? Call toll free 1-800-927-8733 in the United States. Call 510-632-1366 outside of the United States. Fax orders and requests for bulk quantity quotations to 510-568-6040.
Your participation will advance liberty. Join us as an Independent Institute member.
The Independent Institute
100 Swan Way
Oakland, CA 94621-1428
Send us email
Interested in working with us? Click here for more information.
Liberty for Latin America
How to Undo Five Hundred Years of State Oppression
Alvaro Vargas Llosa (Author)
||$6.25 (Save 25%)
In Liberty for Latin America, Alvaro Vargas Llosa offers an incisive diagnosis of Latin Americas woesand a prescription for finally getting the region on the road to both genuine prosperity and the protection of human rights.
When the economy in Argentinaat one time a model of free-market reformcollapsed in 2002, experts of all persuasions asked: What went wrong? Vargas Llosa shows that what went wrong in Argentina has in fact gone wrong all over the continent for over five hundred years. Chronicling Latin Americas political and economic history, he shows how the republics of the 19th century and the revolutions of the 20th centurypopulist uprisings, Marxist coups, state takeovers, and First World-sponsored privatizationhave all run up against the oligarchic legacy of statism. Illiberal elites backed by the U.S. and Europe have perpetuated what he calls the five principles of oppression in order to maintain their hold on power. The region has become a laboratory for political and economic suicide, while comparable countries in Asia and Eastern Europe have prospered.
The only way to change Latin America, Vargas Llosa argues, is to remove the five principles of oppression, genuinely reforming institutions and the underlying culture for the benefit of the disempowered public. In Liberty for Latin America, he explains how, offering hope as well as insight for all those who care for the future of this troubled region.
Table of Contents
1. The Five Principles of Oppression
2. The Twentieth Century: The Hour of the Snail
3. Friendly Fire from the United States
4. What Could Have Been
5. The Liberal Tradition
6. When Things Looked Right, They Were Wrong
Turning the Tide
7. The Fever of Change
8. The Capitalist Mirage
9. Corruption and the Ethical Abyss
10. Liberty for Latin America
- Latin Americas economy experienced temporary growth during the years of economic nationalism and protectionism, but ultimately the results were catastrophic. The GDP annual rate of growth between 1950 and 1980 was 7 percent for Brazil, 6.5 percent for Mexico, 4.9 percent for Peru and 3.8 percent for Argentina. By the 1980s, however, Latin Americas GDP per capita had fallen to less than one-third of the level in the core countries of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD).
- Three major attempts at market reforms took place in Latin America before the 1990s (one in the mid-19th century, another at the turn of the 20th century and the third under military dictatorships in the 1970s). Except in Chile for special reasons that the book discusses, all of them ended up concentrating power in an elite and keeping the masses poor. By repeating many of the mistakes made in previous attempts, Latin America missed a great opportunity in the last couple of decades.
- The crucial mistake made by governments that privatized hundreds of state companies in Latin Americamore than one thousand in Mexico, more than four hundred in Argentina, more than one hundred in Peru was to transfer assets, that is, physical entities, without transferring property rights to all citizens. This is why most of the important privatizations took place under monopoly conditions that have given privatization a bad name. Property is not a physical entity so much as a set of options that the individual can exercise.
- Contrary to conventional wisdom, so-called free-market reform did not reduce the size of government in Latin America. Argentinas GDP grew by 40 percent in the 1990s, but public spending grew by 100 percent. Between 1996 and 2001, Brazil doubled the size of its foreign debt. Except for Chile, where the privatization of old-age pensions has boosted savings and created an important pool of capital (more than $50 billion), privatization was a missed opportunity to vest people with capital across Latin America.
- The creation of regional trade bodies (MERCOSUR being the most notable) ended up restoring many of the trade barriers that governments had set out to eliminate in the early 1990s. In Argentina, MERCOSUR meant that barriers on 71 out of a total of 97 groups of items actually went up even as Argentina was considered a model of commercial liberalization.
- Despite almost $400 billion dollars of foreign investment in the previous decade, Latin Americas investment rate is still an average of 15 percent of GDP because of the prevailing institutional climate. Hundreds of companies have moved their investments from Mexico to China because of the high costs of doing business in the former country (taxes, government-controlled energy, etc.).
- The excess of regulations has expanded the opportunity for corruption. The high cost of doing business, a problem virtually untouched by reform, has turned potential producers into candidates for lucrative government posts or government-protected markets. Brazil has more than 10 million public employees.
- Despite spending more than $25 billion during the 1990s on fighting the drug war overseas, the U.S. government concluded that Plan Colombias failure was a problem of scope. Therefore, in the new decade the U.S. government appropriated another $1.5 billion for Colombias war. Experience shows that every time a significant amount of coca plantations is eliminated in one country, coca leaves immediately crop up in a neighboring country. About 95 percent of all coca plantations eradicated in Bolivia in the last few years were recently planted. The elimination of U.S. agricultural subsidies totalling $50 billion would be a more effective way of drawing Andean peasants away from growing coca leaves.
- In Brazil, pending cases in the courts have increased ten times in the last decade, and there are more than half a million backlogged cases in the Ecuadorian courts. The absence of judicial reform has contributed to perpetuating the absence of the rule of law.
- The regions legal systems, based on a tradition whose remote origins lie in Justinians codified version of Roman law and, much more significantly, in Napoleons positive law, give governments total discretion over everything from constitutional to economic to family matters. Under such arrangements, there is no independent judiciary.
- In order to engage in real reform, the five principles of oppression must be confronted. The entire body of laws should be subjected to a painstaking scrutiny that judges each law by the same standard. The standard is set by five questions: Does it relate to individuals in general or to corporations? Does it make success or failure dependent on state interference? Does it favor particular groups of people and does it therefore discriminate against the rest? Does it transfer wealth from one group of citizens to another? Does its coercive power, either to make something happen or to forbid, derive from political law, that is, from the authority of the politicians and bureaucrats who passed the norms, or, rather, from a higher principle of which those politicians were careful guardians?
- Since reform can hurt those who already depend on the government for basic services, a careful timetable and different ways to ease the transition are suggested. This includes a massive transfer of government assets to public employees and to the very poor, and a change in the legal status of shantytown organizations set up to channel government aid so that they can become incorporated and raise private capital. Also, while the transition lasts, the government should withdraw from the provision of all services, concentrating on providing the funds with which the poor will pay private providers directly, in both health and education.
In Liberty for Latin America: How to Undo Five Hundred Years of State Oppressaion, Alvaro Vargas Llosa maintains that, despite conventional wisdom, no free market reform has taken place in Latin America over the last decades. According to Vargas Llosa, the latest and far-reaching attempt to foster an open society in the region has run up against what he calls the five principles of oppression: corporatism, State mercantilism, privilege, bottom-up wealth redistribution and political law. These same principles of political, social and economic organization have been present in Latin America since time immemorial. They have been sustained, over time, by both the Left and the Right. Unless they are removed once and for all, genuine progress will not be possible.
Seeking to give a comprehensive perspective, Liberty for Latin America accounts for various reform campaigns that have taken place in the region since it gained its independence, all of which, including the most recent one in the 1990s, failed. It also compares this latest attempt with reforms undertaken in other countries, from New Zealand to Central Europe, as well as with the types of institutions that helped develop the leading nations of today.
All of the conclusions are then integrated into a final proposal
for real, meaningful reform. Vargas Llosas proposal postulates
the liberation of the individual from the coercion that
has limited choice, opportunity, wealth creation and access to
property in Latin America. This reform is also an attack on the
deep skepticism and, at times, nihilism into which repeated
failure has thrown large segments of societythe type of environment
in which moral character, and therefore civil society,
can hardly develop.
What Failed in Latin America
Liberty for Latin America is divided into ten chapters, following an introduction that explains how institutions and culture interact in order to bring aboutor stiflethe free society. Chapter 1 looks at how five basic principles of oppression have shaped life in these countries from pre-Columbian to republican times.
Chapter 2 concentrates on the 20th century, up to the end
of the 1980s, a period dominated by economic nationalism that
ended with the collapse of the states legitimacy. As a result,
most of the population had to operate outside of the law, and
various authoritarian movements were able to rally support
against the status quo and the political elites. The long descent
into economic and social devastation is precisely what opened
the way for reform in the final years of the century.
Chapter 3 traces the origin of development in the worlds
leading nations, comparing the types of institutions that made
free-market capitalism possible with Latin Americas principles
of oppression (many of the developed nations have
themselves moved away from the some of the institutions of
liberty, of course).
Success, Real and Imagined
Chapter 4 delves into the tortuous relationship between the
U.S. and Latin America, assessing how various types of policies
(including foreign aid, double standards as regards trade,
Cold War tactics, etc.), have tended to reinforce, rather than
attenuate, the causes of Latin Americas underdevelopment.
Vargas Llosa closely examines the war on drugs and its counterproductive
effect on the whole of the Andean region.
Chapter 5 sets the stage for the following chapters, which
deal with the end-of-century reforms. This particular chapter
analyzes how and why previous attempts at reform failed in
the region, both in the 19th and the 20th centuries. To a large
extent, the same reasons that account for previous failure explain
the recent failure, Vargas Llosa shows.
Chapters 6 and 7 tackle the whole reform process of the 1990s,
including the fight against inflation, privatization, trade liberalization,
foreign investment, and other areas. A detailed description
of what took place in various countries is followed
by a critique seeking to demonstrate that in no area did reform
actually eliminate or substantially reduce the power of the state
over the economy and social life. The moderate successes are
acknowledged, but the failure to take away the monopoly of
opportunity from interest groups linked to the political machinery
is spelled out with a view to helping the reader understand
why there has been no reduction in poverty and why
frustration with free markets is now so pervasive in a region
where reform has come to a complete stop. The conclusion is
that the principles of oppression shaped the reform process
itself, paradoxically entrenching some of the elements reform
was supposed to do away with.
Chapter 8 explores corruption, both in its most blatant
manifestations and in its subtle, extremely harmful social effects,
which account for the absence of a cogent, morally strong,
civil society. The laudable and laborious efforts by grassroots
organizations and civic associations that help sustain life
throughout the region are examined in the context of the pernicious
effect of statism, which is responsible for the emergence
of an entire underclass of marginal people devoid of any sense
of social belonging and for turning social cooperation into a
naked struggle for dwindling handouts at all levels.
Chapter 9 sets the stage for the final chapter, which contains
the proposal for real reform. Here, the book rescues
the individualist tradition of Latin America, valuing the
manifold instances in which individual creativity, social cooperation
and exchange, and resistance against political
oppression have taken place throughout the centuries. This
section demonstrates that real reform must rest on, and draw
inspiration from, a deep-seated, ancient and therefore legitimate
tradition, and that there is nothing alien about liberty
across the region.
Turning the Tide
The final chapter of Liberty for Latin America proposes a direct attack on corporatism, State mercantilism, privilege, wealth transfer and political law through a transformation of the entire political and decision-making system based on the devolution of responsibility to the individual in all spheres of life. The type of reform proposed here has never before been undertaken in Latin America and yet it points to the satisfaction of most of the objectives that previous attempts set out to achieve. Since many individuals depend on the current system for survival, a careful transition is envisioned, including a gradual phasing out of some of the commitments of todays governments. Underlying the entire blueprint for reform is the idea of empowering people at the grassroots level so that the various types of social institutions that are currently hindered from developing and blossoming can restore the moral fiber which society has lost and without which any sort of development is impossible.
If you want to understand why we are poor, why a continent that should be rich has not worked, read Alvaro Vargas Llosas new book, Liberty for Latin America. It is not a repetitive story, nor a simple chronological connection of events, but a sharp historical and economic analysis.... Vargas Llosa solves this puzzle in a pleasant form and with abundant references, allowing all those who want to deeply understand these issues to do so.... Vargas Llosa tells us how northern European countries and the U.S. developed only when they abandoned the mercantilism that was practiced in Europe since the Middle Ages. Such a system, governed by legal positivism and political law, is not based on the recognition of individual rights but on political connections. Under mercantilism, the citizen must serve the government and not the other way around, privileged sectors manage the countrys economy, and a continuous wealth transfer flows from the poor to the rich.
MANUEL AYAU CORDON, Founder, Universidad Francisco Marroquin, Guatemala
You may not agree with everything Alvaro Vargas Llosa says in his Liberty for Latin America, but you should take very seriously his central argument: that lack of political and economic freedom is at the root of our regions underdevelopment. With this volume, Alvaro makes an important contribution to the present debate on the causes of Latin Americas poor economic and social performance.
ERNESTO ZEDILLO, former President of Mexico; Director, Center for the Study of Globalization, Yale University
There is much to admire in Alvaro Vargas Llosas Liberty for Latin America, not least of which its sweep, ranging across centuries of economic history from Mexico to the Southern Cone. He is especially incisive on the free market reforms that became the rage during the 80s and 90s, with Washingtons encouragement, but that have left intact the stagnation and crony capitalism they aimed to end. This is an intriguing manifesto, passionately argued.
SAMUEL DILLON, Pulitzer PrizeWinning New York Times Correspondent and former Mexico City Bureau Chief; co-author, Opening Mexico
"Alvaro Vargas Llosa might be counted among those disciples [of the Austrian school economist Ludwig von Mises] in his eloquent book, Liberty for Latin America. Llosa's impassioned review of 'How to Undo Five Hundred Years of State Oppression' does not spare the United States, which has all too often propped up 'authoritarian, corrupt, and mercantilist institutions.' For the difference between true capitalist reforms and bogus ones, Chapter 8 ('The Capitalist Mirage') makes for especially informative reading."
Alvaro Vargas Llosa has just published a remarkable book, titled Liberty for Latin America. It is a must-read for all those who are interested in the causes of underdevelopment, and especially for those who have hopes of a remedy. Far from being an essay that goes with the wind, the young Vargas Llosa, a veteran journalist and elegant writer, has constructed his study on a solid scientific basis with an intimate knowledge of the Latin American reality.
PEDRO SCHWARTZ, La Vanguardia (Spain); Syndicated Columnist and President of Fundesco
Liberty for Latin America presents Alvaro Vargas Llosas thoughtful analysis of what has impeded Latin Americas progress and what needs to be done. It is well worth reading.
LAWRENCE HARRISON, Professor, Fletcher School, Tufts University; Associate, Academy for International and Area Studies, Harvard University; Author, The Pan-American Dream
Can Latin America overcome underdevelopment and cease to be the poorest and most hopeless segment of the West? Peruvian writer Alvaro Vargas Llosa believes that it can.... The well documented book, which is entertaining despite the topics density, is the fruit of two years of research at the Independent Institute in California.
Why does everything in Latin America usually fail? Vargas Llosa has a daring, but coherent, explanation: Neither the cultural features of Latin America nor its prevailing institutions lead to stability and a growing prosperity.
CARLOS ALBERTO MONTANER, The Miami Herald, Vice President of Liberal International; Syndicated Columnist and Author, Secret Report on the Cuban Revolution
Liberty for Latin America is a gripping account of five hundred years of Latin American oppression. But its not just another re-cycle of that well-worn story. Far from it. Vargas Llosa marshals an impressive array of evidence to successfully make his incisive case: no rule of law, no liberty, no progress. This book is essential reading
STEVE H. HANKE, Professor of Applied Economics, Johns Hopkins University; Columnist, Forbes magazine
In Liberty for Latin America, the brilliant Peruvian writer and journalist, Alvaro Vargas Llosa, relates the immense damage caused by the economic nationalism that has dominated Latin America since the Second World War.... Vargas Llosa blames the Latin American tragedy on the oppression represented by corporativism and state-mercantilism, privilege, wealth transfer and political law.
CARLOS BALL, El Nuevo Herald
The citizenship demands change. But what kind of transformation do we need? The new book by Alvaro Vargas Llosa entitled Liberty for Latin America is a study that we, the Uruguayans, should pay attention to, because it is very appropriate with regard to this change that we are calling for so stridently.
Liberty for Latin America is an analysis of how differing cultures and institutions enable or impede the emergence and flourishing of free, representative governments and broadly productive economies. It is an analysis of the causes and consequences of liberty and oppression in the history of mankind, focusing on and thus constituting the most profound, enlightening study available of Latin American history.
WILLIAM RATLIFF, Research Fellow and Curator of the Americas Collection, Hoover Institution, Stanford University
Alvaro Vargas Llosa is one of Latin Americas foremost political journalists. A native of Peru, he graduated from the London School of Economics and has worked as a journalist in Latin America, Europe and the U.S. for over fifteen years. He is now a Senior Fellow at The Independent Institute.
He has authored twelve books, which have been published in Spanish, English, Portuguese, and Italian. He is also co-author of Guide to the Perfect Latin American Idiot, a bestseller in Latin America, Spain and the United States.
Of Related Interest