The Power of Independent Thinking


Stay Connected
Get the latest updates straight to your inbox.

Volume 17  Number 2  •  Fall 2012
Other Issues:  

Most Economists Welcome Ideological Openness
By William L. Davis, Bob G. Figgins, David Hendengren, Daniel B. Klein
This article appeared in the Fall 2012 issue of The Independent Review

No one argued for ideological openness in the social sciences more extensively than the late Nobel economics laureate Gunnar Myrdal. A survey of economists in the United States finds that 62 percent of respondents would welcome the practice of ideological self-disclosure, suggesting that Myrdal’s proposal may be an idea whose time has come.


With Adam Smith, political economy emerged as part of moral philosophy. From the early 1800s, however, writers have considered whether economics as a science can be demarcated from morals and politics. Can economics be value free? Even if it can be, should it be? During the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, there were strong movements toward demarcation and separation of economics from moral, cultural, and political judgment.

Someone who moves in the world of academic economics now is likely to detect something of an official orthodoxy that economic science should be “positive” and not “normative.” In this view, economists should be factual, analytical, and “objective,” and they should keep their value judgments out of the research....

 PDFRead the Full Article (PDF, 5 pages)

Other Independent Review articles by Daniel B. Klein
    Winter 2018   The Joys of Yiddish and Economics
    Fall 2012   The Improprieties of the Pretense of Knowledge
    Fall 2011   Against Overlordship
[View All (16)]