Richardson et al. (Sci Bull, 2015
) suggest that the irreducibly simple climate model described in Monckton of Brenchley et al. (Sci Bull 60:122135, 2015
) was not validated against observations, relying instead on synthetic test data based on underestimated global warming, illogical parameter choice and near-instantaneous response at odds with ocean warming and other observations. However, the simple model, informed by its authors choice of parameters, usually hindcasts observed temperature change more closely than the general-circulation models, and finds high climate sensitivity implausible.