Print Window   
 
The Independent Institute
Commentary

Does the Surveillance and Security State Make Us Safer?


Yesterday, fellow Forbes contributor Kashmir Hill pointed out that there are giant problems with the NSA’s Utah data center. This is a bad thing, right? Color me unconvinced. I’ll refer you to Glenn Greenwald for in-depth discussion of the legal issues surrounding the NSA’s encroachments on freedom and turn your attention to another, perhaps more practical issue: under what conditions will NSA screening of communications actually work?

For this, we turn to statistics and employ Bayes’ Theorem. In August, we applied Bayes’ Theorem to baseball. Now, let’s apply it to something more serious: catching terrorists.

Suppose the NSA runs your email through a program that is “99% accurate,” meaning that it only makes a mistake one out of every 100 times it runs, and flags you as a potential terrorist. How likely is it that you’re a terrorist?

Read the full article


Art Carden is a Research Fellow at the Independent Institute in Oakland, California, and Assistant Professor of Economics at Samford University.
Full Biography and Recent Publications